This is an excerpt of an article by Richard W. Bann at a Laurel and Hardy website, containing some background information (such as how Quimby wound up at MGM in the first place). Note Hal Roach's evaluation of Quimby toward the end:
Fred Quimby managed production of the short feature department at M-G-M. Besides handling the Roach output, Metro produced its own series, including Carey Wilson Miniatures, John Nesbitt's Passing Parade, and the Crime Does Not Pay series. Quimby previously held the corresponding post at Pathe and moved to Metro in tandem with Roach in l927. So by l936 Quimby and Roach had worked together for two decades. When so many Loew's regional branch managers besieged Quimby for Laurel & Hardy short product, he telephoned Roach on November ll, l936. Both men understood the business reasons precluding the production of new two-reelers starring Laurel & Hardy. Since Roach could no longer manufacture shorts for the money that Metro was willing to pay to serve a dwindling audience, reissuing old subjects was the only solution to their problem. During the l920s and l930s films might remain in original release for about a year, and were thought to have a shelf life of about a decade. Roach's distribution agreement with M-G-M did provide for a ten year term, and he promised to nominate three subjects for Quimby's consideration.
Roach conferred with Matthew D. O'Brien to make a selection. O'Brien and Roach were boyhood friends from Elmira. In l936 O'Brien was general manager and secretary-treasurer of Hal Roach Studios, Inc. Together they selected three titles both men liked and O'Brien phoned Quimby. In response, Quimby sent O'Brien this letter on November l8: "Confirming our telephone conversation believe that following two-reel Laurel and Hardy comedies will be satisfactory for reissue, however, would like to see print of each before making definite decision: PERFECT DAY, NIGHT OWLS, BLOTTO. Believe that we also should look at print of the four-reel subject BEAU HUNKS with the thought of reissuing it, to be used as a second feature in double feature houses. Discussed the two-reel reissuing with Mr. Roach but did not discuss reissuing of BEAU HUNKS, however, am quite certain that he will be agreeable to the plan."
He was, as noted in hand by O'Brien on Quimby's letter. Whether it was Quimby or someone else who suggested re-releasing COUNTY HOSPITAL instead of NIGHT OWLS is not known. In l98l Hal Roach did not recall much about this, but did say of Fred Quimby, "He was a competent executive, I trusted him, but he was completely humorless. Why Louie Mayer placed him in charge of shorts there, I never understood. I mean the Pete Smith Specialties, the Bob Benchley things, the cartoons, they were comedies. Quimby never knew what was funny, or why."
Fred Quimby retired from M-G-M in l955. Animators of the Tom & Jerry cartoons, Bill Hanna and Joe Barbera, replaced him. By then one-reel cartoons were virtually the only shorts one could see on theater screens.
The entire article can be found here:
http://www.laurel-and-hardy.com/featuresho...ie/0017/17.htmlMichael